Product Reviews

ColourPop Super Shock Eyeshadow Review and Swatches

January 15, 2015

Hi Everyone!

I have jumped on the ColourPop train. Is anyone shocked? I’m not. I have been curious about these shadows for so long, so with some of my Christmas money I decided to suck up the Canadian shipping (14.99?!…ouch) and make these babies mine. I got them last week and after taking some time to play with them I’m going to share my thoughts with you today.


As usual, we’re going to first look at the packaging.


ColourPop is based in California, so I was a bit worried about it getting to me intact. Luckily, there was a ton of care packed into the box and everything arrived as it should. Usually with cosmetics, you might get some bubble wrap or packing peanuts, but with this it came wrapped in a thick layer of of foam which filled the entire box. I was so impressed. Plus it was marked fragile on the outside, something I see less and less on the packages I receive. So far, so great I say.


So once I got through the foam, I found a sweet handwritten thank you note addressed to me. If you’re familiar with ColourPop, then you’ll know that they actually do this for every package, which is such a nice personal touch. It might be small, but this kind of stuff takes time, so I do appreciate it.


Once I got through that, I made it to the shadows. Each came in it’s own little teal and white box and the side of each box reminds you to keep the lids closed tightly to ‘keep the magic in’. I seriously have become so paranoid about the lids being tight, I literally lay in bed wondering if all the lids are tight enough…ya…errr…we’ll refer to that as dedication. The packaging is so adorable and so nice considering these shadows are only $5. You just don’t see presentation like that often on affordable products. The only knock I have against the outer packaging is that the names weren’t written on the outside, so I did have to open them to see which shade was which. So minor since the shade names are on the shadows themselves. I’m being picky.


As for a packaging of the shadows themselves, these come in little white pots with screw caps. Since these aren’t regular shadows (I’ll get to this), they can’t be depotted from my understanding as they need to be airtight. I usually don’t gravitate to single eyeshadows and I actually don’t really own any, but these are an exception. I’m not really bothered that I can’t depot them surprisingly. The only thing I will say about the screw cap is that if you’re hands are wet or greasy, they are pretty hard to get off. This morning I put some oil in my hair and then went to open one and my hand was sliding all over the place. Once again, minor. I think overall the packaging is so well done and looks so sleek. It’s completely my style.



Now onto the good part, the shadows. These are so unique, it’s almost impossible to describe. The texture of these is like a cool mousse type texture.Β  It’s like a gel-mousse formula. I don’t consider these to be like cream shadows at all. These are so different than cream eyeshadows because they set like a powder and they don’t crease. Also unlike cream shadows, these don’t need anything on top to set, they are good to go on their own! A lot of the shades I chose are quite shimmery and some have glitter, but you can’t feel it at all. These are completely smooth. To go along with that, these have absolutely no fall out or at least I haven’t experienced any. Pretty incredible, right?


They do recommend that you apply these with your fingers. For the purposes of this review I tried that method and I also used a brush to see how they would perform. I used my finger and got excellent pigmentation, but a bit of a messy application. It’s not my favourite method. It has nothing to do with the shadows, just my personal preference. I decided to use a brush and I still got good pigmentation, but I did need to build it up a tiny bit more. After both I prefer to initially use the brush to get the colour exactly where I want it and then add a little with my finger for an extra pop. In the crease, the brush does totally fine. Both methods work really well, it’s totally preference here.


Okay so now onto the really good part, the swatches. I picked up 14 shades in a variety of finishes, so you’ll get to see a pretty wide range.




3- a brown base with lots of multi-coloured and silver glitter.




Amaze- Amaze is a soft rose gold shade that is quite shimmery, but doesn’t have any big flecks of glitter. This leans more toward copper than pink if that makes sense.




Bandit- a matte warm brown with strong red undertones. I love this shade, it’s the perfect shade for deepening up a look but giving it warmth at the same time.

Cop a Feel



Cop a Feel- This shade is pretty close to my skin tone, so it doesn’t have a ton of impact on me, but it is nice for cleaning up edges and blending. It is a matte beige with some soft peach undertones.




Desert- A warm satin camel brown.




Fringe- A soft champagne gold with silver and gold shimmer. I love these kind of shades, not too gold, but perfect to add something to an every day eye look.




Girly- Vanilla with reflects of pink and gold. This shade is really unique, but it does better as a topper. On it’s own it’s just not quite enough for me. Not that it’s not pigmented, but it’s pretty light. As a topper it really brings attention to the centre of the lid. It is an excellent brow bone or inner corner highlight, which is what I like to use it for the most.




Hustle- A deep matte purple-burgundy. I love these kind of shades, they are so flattering on hazel eyes. I love this in the crease, it’s dark but not flat.




Mittens- A matte warm cocoa brown that is much less red than Bandit. This is perfect for deepening up the lower lashline or in the crease.

On the Rocks



On the Rocks- a brassy bronze with lots of multi-coloured glitter.




Play- A medium caramel coloured shade with peach undertones. This shade makes a great transition shade on my skin tone.

So Quiche



So Quiche- Olive with pink-violet and gold glitter. This might be my favourite shade of all the ones I have. It’s so unique.




Sunnies- A medium burnt orange shade. This might seem totally random since I don’t really wear a ton of bright shades. Lately I’ve been really curious about using an orange shade in the crease to really add warmth. I really like how this looks when it’s all blended out, it adds another dimension to an eye look. Will I wear this on the lid? Probably not, but I do really like it in the crease. It looks a little scary at first, but just keep blending and it looks amazing.

Tea Party



Tea Party- A peachy pink shade with loads of glitter in it. This shade is pretty on top of Amaze and I think it would look nice on top of a matte peach like Nectar from the Lorac Pro Palette 2. This kind of shade just really makes you look girly and fresh.

So there are all the shades I chose. I did want to include a sample look as well, so you can see what these look like on. Here is the quick eye look I wore today.


This mainly features Hustle (crease and outer V) and So Quiche (lid) but I also used Cop a Feel, Bandit and Desert.

Final Thoughts

These are amazing. They have so many unique shades and the price point is great. I really haven’t found any flaws. They wear well throughout the day, are pigmented, they don’t crease and I haven’t experienced any fall out. I can’t really ask for much more. The ONLY thing if I was to ask for anything is for them to improve their shipping. It was expensive and they don’t ship international yet, which is so sucky. I hear that they’re working on that though. In all, these 100% live up to the hype. Plus the company is so sassy and I love a company that can have a little fun, I mean makeup is supposed to be fun.

What do you think of these? Have you tried anything from ColourPop?

Bye for now!


You Might Also Like


  • Reply hannkingxo January 15, 2015 at 1:28 am

    I have never heard of this brand but this eyeshadows look like a ‘I Need This’ product! I love the colour Amaze and Cop a Feel!

    Hannah | hannerking | a beauty and lifestyle blog


    • Reply Chelsey January 15, 2015 at 1:30 am

      Ya they seemed to come out of nowhere some time last year. They are really making a name for themselves!

  • Reply Sarah's Colors Make-up Artist January 15, 2015 at 1:36 am

    Do want to try it. They dont deliver in europe 😭

    • Reply Chelsey January 15, 2015 at 1:36 am

      I know, its so sucky! I hear they’re working on that so very soon hopefully!

  • Reply TheMakeupCase17 January 15, 2015 at 2:00 am

    I plan on trying some stuff from them sometime this year.

    • Reply Chelsey January 15, 2015 at 10:02 am

      You definitely should!

  • Reply plus+beauty27 January 15, 2015 at 4:43 am

    These look wonderful! I recently placed an order with Color Pop, just ordered a lip color is all but I will definitely have to place an order for the shadows sometime as well. πŸ™‚

    • Reply Chelsey January 15, 2015 at 10:03 am

      You definitely should, they’re really good!

  • Reply lush4blush January 15, 2015 at 11:28 am

    I love the shades you picked! Def need to go run to get more!

    • Reply Chelsey January 15, 2015 at 11:30 am

      They have so many amazing shades, it was so hard for me to restrain myself! haha. I think I need to dive into the lippie sticks and pencils next.

      • Reply lush4blush January 15, 2015 at 11:31 am

        Omg yes! I only have 5 lippie stix from the “Lippie to Go” set but it was a great introduction to them. I need to get more fo sho.

  • Reply rachelellisfashionandbeauty January 15, 2015 at 2:35 pm

    I have heard of these before and would love to get my hands on some but I live in the UK πŸ™ They are stunning though πŸ™‚ xx

  • Reply Julia Brooks January 15, 2015 at 8:44 pm

    obsessed with that color Sunnies. so glad you hopped on the bandwagon! xo

    • Reply Chelsey January 15, 2015 at 9:08 pm

      Sunnies is such a pretty shade! I’m glad too!

  • Reply Miss White's Makeup Desk January 17, 2015 at 5:26 am

    AWESOME haul! So jealous! Been lusting after these products after Shaaanxo talked about them! Great blog too – just followed you πŸ™‚

  • Reply January 2015 Favourites | Makeup By Chelsey January 30, 2015 at 3:39 pm

    […] you’re curious about ColourPop, I do have a full review dedicated to these […]

  • Reply Jennifer February 5, 2015 at 10:29 pm

    I really want to try their eyeshadows & lippie stixs! Did you had to pay custom fees or any additional fees when they arrived? I don’t want to pay $14.99 for shipping and then another $20 for custom fees.

    • Reply Chelsey February 5, 2015 at 10:38 pm

      I didn’t have to pay anything extra!

    Leave a Reply