Collection Series Part 3: Eyeshadow Palettes

November 29, 2014

Hi Everyone!

I’m back today with part 3 of my collection series! We have reached one of my greatest weaknesses and one of the biggest parts of my collection, my eye shadow palettes. Eye shadows are one of my favourite parts of makeup and I have accumulated a lot of great palettes that I can’t wait to share with you. I didn’t swatch these in this post because there are quite a few, but if there are specific swatches you would like to see just let me know and I can do that. I will also link any related reviews I’ve done if you want to see any of these palettes more in depth.



The first palettes I want to share with you are the only drugstore palettes I currently have in my collection. I have a weakness for eye shadows like I said I have had great luck with high end in this case. That being said, these palettes from ELF are still very good quality for their price. These are my go-to for brighter shades. Since I don’t tend to wear tons of bright colours I’m not going to spend tons on high end bright shades since I wouldn’t get tons of wear out of them. These fill my need for bright shades.

100 Piece Eyeshadow Palette

The 100 Piece Eyeshadow Palette is pretty pigmented for only being $10 full price and I did use this on Halloween on a friend of mine and it worked out amazing. You can see I have hit pan on some of the lighter, neutral shades. In the year up until I started this blog, this was all I had and used for eyeshadows and I wore those shades every single day.

32 Piece Geometric Eyeshadow Palette

The second palette is the 32 Piece Geometric Eyeshadow Palette. These are also very good quality, considering its only $12 full price. If I need some good purples, I go right for this.

Too Faced Palettes

TooFaced Palettes

A Few of My Favorite Things

The first Too Faced palette in my collection is from their 2013 holiday collection. I got this just before Christmas last year, so it’s not available anymore but they do have a palette in the holiday collection this year that is quite similar. This is a do-it all kind of palette. You can pack this and you have your shadows and your blush and bronzer all in one handy spot. The shadows are beautiful and perfect for the holidays, as most of them are pretty shimmery. I would have liked a few more mattes included as I think it’s easier to get a complete eye look if there’s more matte shades. All in all, it was great value for it’s price.

Related Reviews:

A Few of My Favorite Things

Chocolate Bar

The Chocolate Bar Palette

Now onto the Chocolate Bar Palette. This is a great palette. It has what I like to call ‘pumped-up neutrals’. If you like neutral shades, but you still like it to look interesting, then this is for you. It has a good amount of mattes in both transition and crease colours and it also has neutral lid colours that are still interesting to the eye. I highly recommend this one.

Urban Decay Naked Palettes


Now onto the Naked Palettes, probably the most hyped up palettes to ever be made. These are so popular, but to be completely honest now that I’ve tried many different brands of eyeshadows, Urban Decay does not make the best shadows. It’s not that they aren’t good, they are but I just prefer other brands such as Lorac over these.

Naked 2

I went through this phase, where these were like Pokemon and I just had to catch em all. I probably could have passed on the Naked 2. I just find it to be so dark and hard to wear for daytime. The shadows are beautiful, but I think my style has just changed because I tend to go warm now and the Naked 2 is pretty cool-toned and maybe not as flattering on my skin tone.

Naked 3

The Naked 3 is definitely flattering on my skin tone and with my eye colour, but it is best used with other palettes in my opinion because I end up with a very similar look each time using it on it’s own.


The original Naked Palette is my favourite of the three, likely since it’s the most warm. This just works perfect for day time makeup, this is the one I suggest to anyone who wants to buy just one. In general all of these palettes have tons of shimmer, which Urban Decay does pretty often so that’s something to keep in mind.

Related Reviews:

A Comparison of All 3



Now we’ve have moved onto Lorac. By far my favourite eyeshadow formula I have tried. These are the most buttery shadows to ever grace my eyelids…seriously. I have talked about these tons and for good reason, they are so pigmented- it is beyond impressive.

Lorac Pro Palettes

The first of three Lorac Palettes I have is the original Pro Palette. This is a staple to me. I think if you own one high end palette, one of these should be it. The original Pro is warm in tone, which is flattering on my cool skin. With a row of matte and a row of shimmer in each, you can just take this and be good to go. The Pro 2 is more cool toned, but it does still have shades with warm undertones and some warm shades so it still works amazing for me. I can’t rave enough about these, they are worth well beyond $42. Since I’m in Canada and we can’t get Lorac here I did buy these in the US, but we can now get Lorac on!

Lorac Mega Pro

I have talked about this quite a bit recently, but this is like my palette heaven. I already love Lorac shadows, but then I get 32 all in one place…*angels singing*. These are the same great quality as the Pro Palettes and it incredible variety. It’s super impossible to get now, but I hope Lorac does this style of palette again because it’s perfect.

Related Reviews:

Pro 2

Mega Pro


Stila Palette

Stila in the Light Palette

I only have one Stila palette currently in my collection and it’s In the Light Palette. I won this in a giveaway this past summer and I went through an obsessed phase with it. It has made it’s way to the back of the drawer mainly because I have been giving some new to me stuff a little more attention. This is insanely flattering on blue eyes, it makes them pop. I still wear this on my hazel eyes and it works well for that too. It has their famous kitten shade, which is the perfect no makeup makeup type of shade. Brightens the face, but it’s still soft. This entire palette is perfect for the no makeup makeup type of look. I loved it during the summer when I was wearing much lighter looks. The shade on the bottom left called Bubbly is my perfect gold because it’s not super yellow which is often why I don’t wear tons of gold.

Make Up For Ever


Lastly we have my MUFE Artist Shadows. These are brand new and I talked about them in my IMATS haul, so I won’t blab on too much. I am still testing these out, but so far I have had great luck. They are very pigmented and buttery soft.

Shades (left to right):

I804- Golden Pink

M928- Eggplant

D562- Taupe Platinum

ME612- Silver Brown

I524- Piny Beige

ME302- Peacock

M822- Plum

So there you have it, you have made it through my eye shadow collection! I hope you enjoyed this post and I will be back again soon!

Bye for now,




You Might Also Like


  • Reply plus+beauty27 November 29, 2014 at 2:14 pm

    Very envious of all of your palettes! They’re all gorgeous! 🙂

  • Reply Suzanne November 29, 2014 at 11:19 pm

    I love your blog and this review is amazing! I have been debating over the elf palette for so long, like you I don’t reach for the bright colors first but def would like to invest in a palette for color varieties. Have you tried any of the Ulta palettes with so much selections as elf and at the elf price?

    • Reply Chelsey November 30, 2014 at 2:17 am

      Thank you! The ELF palette is great value for only $10 full price so I think its the perfect way to add some colour and not spend a lot. I actually haven’t tried anything from the Ulta brand. I’m in Canada so I have only been to Ulta once since we don’t have it here. I wish we did because I loved it!

  • Reply ana bragg makeup December 1, 2014 at 10:30 am

    I put the ZPalette on my Christmas list—hopefully Santa brings it to me!

    • Reply Chelsey December 2, 2014 at 12:02 am

      They are so awesome! I think I’m addicted!

  • Reply mybeautysanctuary December 4, 2014 at 4:06 pm

    I really love the too faced and urban decay palettes

  • Reply Alexis Ruiz December 13, 2014 at 11:12 am

    Mmm which Lorac palette would you buy first if you did not have either Pro or Pro2? Would love to buy either or!

    • Reply Chelsey December 13, 2014 at 11:16 am

      Hmm that’s a tough one! The original Pro has more staple colours, but the Pro 2 has some amazing shades. It really depends what shadows you already have in your collection. You can’t go wrong! Based on my collection I love them both equally but I pick up the Pro 2 more.

      • Reply Alexis Ruiz December 13, 2014 at 11:20 am

        Thanks for your honest opinion and they both look so pigmented and feel creamy when I tested them out in Sephora :(( so it is a very hard decision xD!!

        • Reply Chelsey December 13, 2014 at 11:22 am

          Extremely hard! But whatever one you pick can’t be a bad decision because they are both amazing! Lorac makes my favourite eye shadows.

  • Reply Collection Series Part 4: Pigments and Glitters | Makeup By Chelsey January 10, 2015 at 12:58 am

    […] Collection Series Part 3: Eyeshadow Palettes […]

  • Leave a Reply